Advice on Thanksgiving Wine

Americans reap a bounty of advice on Thanksgiving wine
by Leslie Gevirtz, | New York
November 26, 2013

As Americans search for that perfect wine to complement the traditional Thanksgiving feast, experts smile, give a slight shake of their heads and say, just drink what you like.

With so many different competing flavors at the Thanksgiving table, including the turkey, wines can be matched to the cranberry dressing, or even the marshmallows on the sweet potatoes, according to Doug Frost, a wine consultant for United Airlines.

"What I do is put out several different wines on the table," said Frost, who holds the expert titles of Master Sommelier and Master of Wine. "I'm a big fan of dry rosé and they are from all over these days: Italy, Spain, the U.S., of course."

Jennifer Simonetti-Bryan, who also has a Master of Wine title, said that for the last decade everyone has talked about Pinot Noir with turkey.

"It's like the perfect cranberry and turkey pairing, but in a glass," she said.

Simonetti-Bryan, whose latest wine course "The Everyday Guide to Wine" is on DVD, said the problem with Pinot Noir is that it is difficult to find a good quality one for under $20.

"Pinot Noir, as a grape, is kind of like the high-priced, fashion supermodel who doesn't get out of bed for less than $100,000. It's amazing, but you're going to have to pay for it," she explained.

Instead, she suggested an Austrian red, Blaufrankisch, that is similar to Pinot Noir and sells for less than $20 a bottle. Blaufrankisch has a little darker character than a Pinot Noir, "but it has a softness and a nice pepperiness that complements not only Thanksgiving Turkey, but also sage stuffing."

Two of her favorites are Weingut J. Heinrich Blaufrankisch and Nittnaus Blaufrankisch, which each cost about $16 a bottle.

Master of Wine Lisa Granik, who will be spending Thanksgiving in Australia where she expects to be eating kangaroo and drinking Australian Barossa Shiraz, is usually partial to California Zinfandels to pair with the traditional turkey meal, especially those from Turley Wine Cellars.

The prices for Turley's Old Vines, Mead Ranch or Pesenti Zinfandels range from about $26 to more than $50 a bottle.

In addition to the dry rosé, Frost said he loves German Rieslings, especially a Spatlese, with turkey. Joh. Jos. Prum's Riesling Spatlese sells for about $30 a bottle. For a red wine, he prefers Beaujolais Crus or any red Rhone wines, which range from $8 to $20 a bottle, depending on the producer.

For the dessert course, Frost suggests a late-harvest Vidal Blanc, which sells for up to $12, or a more expensive ice wine at $40 for a half bottle, as good pairings with pumpkin pie.

"They both have an insipient tartness to them. They come off real sweet at first and then get tart near the end. Pumpkin pie needs a powerful wine, not a super-sweet one," he said.

Read the article online here.


Recent Appearances

Gotham Magazine

Click on the photo to download the PDF.

Read More
Why Is Rosé Running Low in the Hamptons?
Read More
New York Women Make Marks as Masters of Wine

By Lettie Teague August 14, 2014 It's no secret that some of the most accomplished and ambitious women in the world live in New York. What's not well known is that several are Masters of Wine. Considered by many to be the single greatest achievement in the wine world, the Masters of Wine diploma can […]

Read More
Good Day Cafe: Sangria

New York News

Read More


© 2020 Jennifer Simonetti-Bryan
Powered by Simply
Digital Workshop